The game, between Juventus A and Juventus B, is played yearly in the town of Villar Perosa outside of Turin.
The 33-year-old, who signed from Real Madrid for £99.2m in July, scored the first goal in Sunday's 5-0 victory.
The match was called off after 72 minutes due to the annual tradition of fans running onto the pitch.
The Agnelli family, who own the Serie A champions, own an estate in Villar Perosa and have invited the teams to play a friendly every year since 1955.
Juventus B won the first game 3-2 but they have not beaten the first team in the match since 2005.
best soccer prediction site